Tuesday, November 17, 2026
  • Login
CEO North America
  • Home
  • News
    • Business
    • Entrepreneur
    • Industry
    • Innovation
    • Management & Leadership
  • CEO Interviews
  • Opinion
  • Technology
  • Environment
  • CEO Life
    • Art & Culture
    • Food
    • Health
    • Travel
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Business
    • Entrepreneur
    • Industry
    • Innovation
    • Management & Leadership
  • CEO Interviews
  • Opinion
  • Technology
  • Environment
  • CEO Life
    • Art & Culture
    • Food
    • Health
    • Travel
No Result
View All Result
CEO North America
No Result
View All Result

CEO NA Magazine > Opinion > How Higher Pay Incentives Can Backfire

How Higher Pay Incentives Can Backfire

in Opinion
How Higher Pay Incentives Can Backfire
Share on LinkedinShare on WhatsApp

In the mid-1990s, Safelite, a windshield repair company, made a bold move. It replaced hourly wages with performance-based pay, offering employees the chance to earn more money the more windshields they installed. The results were striking.

Within a year, productivity surged by approximately 44 percent.

“That’s a massive increase,” says George Georgiadis, an associate professor of strategy at the Kellogg School of Management and an expert on performance-based incentives.

The reason for this productivity bump was nuanced. About half of the increase came from existing workers putting in more effort. The other half was due to a shift in the type of employees Safelite attracted. “The least productive employees left, and the new hires who replaced them were significantly more skilled and productive,” Georgiadis explains.

Safelite’s success story quickly became a textbook example in economics, illustrating how performance-based pay could boost productivity by both motivating current workers and attracting better talent.

Inspired by this example, many companies came to believe that continually increasing incentives—such as bonuses, commissions, or stock options—would naturally attract the best talent and drive productivity even higher. Indeed, many growth-focused companies, including tech giants like Google and Netflix, have adopted increasingly generous incentive structures, hoping to attract and retain top talent and keep profits climbing.

Yet despite its widespread popularity, this approach has a critical blind spot. It assumes that steepening incentives always leads to better employee selection—that it will attract more high-skilled and productive workers. But research by Georgiadis and his colleague Henrique Castro-Pires of the University of Miami challenges this assumption.

The hidden downsides of steeper incentives

To that end, Castro-Pires and Georgiadis developed a mathematical model to explore how prospective employees respond to changes to incentive pay structures.

Their model considers the following scenario.

An employer, such as the manager at an organization, posts a job that offers performance-based pay.

Potential applicants—who vary in skill level—decide whether to apply based on how compelling the pay structure is compared with their other job opportunities. Each applicant undergoes a screening test that high-skilled applicants have a higher likelihood of passing than low-skilled applicants.The employer then chooses whom to hire among the applicants who pass the test, and each hired worker decides how hard to work.

Common wisdom suggests that increasing incentives would naturally attract more high-skilled applicants. But the researchers found that higher incentives tend to attract both more high-skilled and more low-skilled applicants.

In fact, depending on the job market, steeper incentives can disproportionately attract low-skilled workers. High-skilled workers often have more and better job opportunities than low-skilled workers, making them relatively scarce in the applicant pool. As a result, increasing incentives can inadvertently increase the proportion of low-skilled applicants, ultimately harming the quality of the employer’s workforce.

Practical steps for employers

While the researchers’ model doesn’t provide a one-size-fits-all solution, it does offer practical guidance for companies looking to optimize their incentive pay structures.

Georgiadis suggests that employers should design incentives that specifically appeal to high-skilled employees more than they do to low-skilled employees.

“If you simply increase pay across the board, everyone benefits and more people apply from both pools,” Georgiadis says. “But if you restructure incentives so that high-skilled employees are better off while low-skilled employees are not, then you improve selection by attracting more of the former.”

Read the full article by Abraham Kim, Henrique Castro-Pires and George Georgiadis / Kellogg Insights

Related Posts

Music can help prevent cognitive decline
Opinion

To optimize consumer experiences, don’t always rely on saving the best for last

3 Key Takeaways from Trump Tax Cuts on US Consumer Spending
Opinion

How high-income earners can reduce taxes before year-end

What great artists can teach us about great leadership
Opinion

What great artists can teach us about great leadership

8 Leadership Strategies from Top Performers
Opinion

Reimagining Organizational Transformation Strategies for Today’s Companies

The real value of vendor partnerships for CIOs
Opinion

How board dynamics and behaviours impact governance

Building Executive Presence in Today’s Workplace
Opinion

Building Executive Presence in Today’s Workplace

What Executive Presence Means for Women in Leadership
Opinion

What Executive Presence Means for Women in Leadership

Leading With Grounded Confidence
Opinion

Leading With Grounded Confidence

Onboarding Best Practices: Maximum Value From New Hires
Opinion

Onboarding Best Practices: Maximum Value From New Hires

Lead for Sustainable Performance
Opinion

Lead for Sustainable Performance

No Result
View All Result

Recent Posts

  • To optimize consumer experiences, don’t always rely on saving the best for last
  • Amazon to invest $7 billion in renewable energy in India
  • IMF chief gives stark warning on global economy 
  • Disney beats earnings expectations as park attendance grows
  • Home Depot names Richard McPhail CEO amid leadership reshuffle

Archives

Categories

  • Art & Culture
  • Business
  • CEO Interviews
  • CEO Life
  • Editor´s Choice
  • Entrepreneur
  • Environment
  • Food
  • Health
  • Highlights
  • Industry
  • Innovation
  • Issues
  • Management & Leadership
  • News
  • Opinion
  • PrimeZone
  • Printed Version
  • Technology
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

  • CONTACT
  • GENERAL ENQUIRIES
  • ADVERTISING
  • MEDIA KIT
  • DIRECTORY
  • TERMS AND CONDITIONS

Advertising –
advertising@ceo-na.com

110 Wall St.,
3rd Floor
New York, NY.
10005
USA
+1 2125 9933 0330

UK
Collingwood Buildings,
38 Collingwood Street,
Newcastle Upon Tyne
NE1 1JF

  • News
  • CEO Interviews
  • Opinion
  • Technology
  • Environment
  • CEO Life

  • CONTACT
  • GENERAL ENQUIRIES
  • ADVERTISING
  • MEDIA KIT
  • DIRECTORY
  • TERMS AND CONDITIONS

Advertising –
advertising@ceo-na.com

110 Wall St.,
3rd Floor
New York, NY.
10005
USA
+1 2125 9933 0330

UK
Collingwood Buildings,
38 Collingwood Street,
Newcastle Upon Tyne
NE1 1JF

CEO North America © 2024 - Sitemap

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Business
    • Entrepreneur
    • Industry
    • Innovation
    • Management & Leadership
  • CEO Interviews
  • Opinion
  • Technology
  • Environment
  • CEO Life
    • Art & Culture
    • Food
    • Health
    • Travel

© 2026 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.