Saturday, August 20, 2022
  • Login
CEO North America
  • Home
  • Business
    • Entrepreneur
    • Industry
    • Innovation
    • Management & Leadership
  • CEO Interviews
  • CEO Life
    • Art & Culture
    • Food
    • Health
    • Travel
    • Environment
  • Opinion
  • News
  • Multimedia
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
    • Entrepreneur
    • Industry
    • Innovation
    • Management & Leadership
  • CEO Interviews
  • CEO Life
    • Art & Culture
    • Food
    • Health
    • Travel
    • Environment
  • Opinion
  • News
  • Multimedia
No Result
View All Result
CEO North America
No Result
View All Result

Why Locking In Subscribers Is Bad for Business

in Opinion
Why locking in subscribers is bad for business
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Promotional offers for newspapers, gym memberships, internet and phone services, and other subscription-based businesses sometimes come with a catch: after a honeymoon period of reduced pricing, the business renews the membership automatically, at a higher price. Then customers may find themselves unwittingly paying a recurring membership for something they don’t fully use or want.

Many people are too busy, forgetful, or distracted to unsubscribe, and some companies lean on this consumer inertia to boost revenues. But this kind of exploitation may come back to bite them in the long run, suggests research by HEC Paris’s Klaus M. Miller, Stanford’s Navdeep S. Sahni, and Chicago Booth’s Avner Strulov-Shlain.

The researchers ran a field experiment tracking promotion-backed online subscriptions to a well-known European newspaper between 2018 and 2020. The newspaper ran a range of promotions offering free access or access at €0.99 for two- or four-week periods, culminating in either an automatic full-priced subscription or automatic cancellation. The researchers looked at eight promotional groups in total.

Miller, Sahni, and Strulov-Shlain had access to the browsing history of more than 1 million potential subscribers from 14 days prior to the promotions to 27 days after. The newspaper also provided two years’ worth of customer relationship management data on all subscriptions and contracts.

The researchers find that in the long run, the promotions automatically enrolling website users in an ongoing subscription at regular prices were considerably less successful than those that were obligation free or simply ended with cancellation. Automatic renewals attracted about a quarter fewer subscribers to the promo.

Thanks, but no thanks

When a newspaper offered potential subscribers a discounted promotion that led to an automatic renewal at expiration, most consumers either avoided it or quickly canceled.

This is most likely because these consumers were aware of the downside of their own future inertia when it came to proactively unsubscribing, the researchers say. Consumers significantly underestimated their own inertia, the researchers write, and yet many still demonstrated a sophisticated understanding of it. “When they were offered something that would ultimately tie them into a situation that their own inertia would make it hard to break, they were overwhelmingly less inclined to sign up for it there and then,” says Strulov-Shlain.

Readers who received an offer tying them into automatic renewal were 9 percent less inclined to sign up for a subscription at any point during the two years following the promotion period, relative to those who’d been able to sign up obligation free. The mere offer of an automatic subscription renewal put them off signing up, the researchers speculate.

Even though the newspaper reported a 21 percent increase in revenue from these unwilling subscribers immediately following the promotions, the benefit quickly faded. After one year, the revenue generated from both promotional offers was equivalent, and there were more subscribers from the promotion that automatically canceled.

Any short-term revenue gains that were due to the inertia of subscribers who were automatically enrolled were outweighed by the longer-term effect, as locked-in customers gradually left, the researchers find.

“Subscription-based businesses focus on customer retention over customer acquisition, so if this is your model, you really need to pay attention to the data,” says Strulov-Shlain. Locking in people turns off customers and deters potential ones, he adds.

Strulov-Shlain thinks that a better strategy for subscription-based businesses is to make it transparently easy for people to leave when they want to. He points to Netflix and Amazon as companies that offer customers the option to cancel their subscriptions easily.

“They’ve understood that exploiting consumer inertia isn’t healthy for long-term business,” he says. “At the end of the day, it’s as true of subscription business models as it is of all human relationships: you just can’t simply force people to love you.”

(Courtesy Chicago Booth Review. By Áine Doris)

Tags: Chicago Booth

Related Posts

How listening to the business ecosystem can turn unpredictability into opportunity
Management & Leadership

How listening to the business ecosystem can turn unpredictability into opportunity

How the ceo’s leadership in digital transformation can tip the scales toward success
Opinion

How the CEO’s leadership in digital transformation can tip the scales toward success

Automaker ceos urge congress to lift ev tax credit cap
Opinion

Mobility in the eye of the storm

Beyond “agree to disagree”: why leaders need to foster a culture of productive disagreement and debate
Management & Leadership

Beyond “agree to disagree”: why leaders need to foster a culture of productive disagreement and debate

A new globalization calculus
Opinion

A new globalization calculus

The chips act: what it means for the semiconductor ecosystem
Opinion

The CHIPS Act: What it means for the semiconductor ecosystem

Beyond the ‘lamppost theory’ of economic policy
Opinion

Beyond the ‘lamppost theory’ of economic policy

Should airbnb and amazon hoard information to maximize revenue?
Opinion

In a tight labor market, remote work makes inroads

From tailwinds to turbulence
Business

From tailwinds to turbulence

The wild west of renewables: accounting for energy tax credits
Opinion

The wild west of renewables: accounting for energy tax credits

No Result
View All Result

Recent Posts

  • Embracing a Digital Approach / Harvard Business School
  • Why reporting workplace well-being metrics is a good idea
  • GM restores quarterly dividend after more than two years
  • Foot Locker names Mary Dillon as next CEO, Dick Johnson to retire
  • Bed Bath & Beyond shares sink 40% after Ryan Cohen completes sale

Recent Comments

    Archives

    Categories

    • Art & Culture
    • Business
    • CEO Interviews
    • CEO Life
    • Editor´s Choice
    • Entrepreneur
    • Environment
    • Food
    • Health
    • Highlights
    • Industry
    • Innovation
    • Issues
    • Management & Leadership
    • Multimedia
    • News
    • Opinion
    • PrimeZone
    • Printed Version
    • Travel
    • Uncategorized

    Meta

    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.org

    CEO Latin America | ES

    • CONTACT
    • GENERAL ENQUIRIES
    • ADVERTISING
    • MEDIA KIT
    • DIRECTORY
    • TERMS AND CONDITIONS

    Editorials – george.hatfield@ceo-na.com
    Editor-in-Chief - paul.imison@ceo-na.com
    Advertising – media@ceo-na.com

    AUSTIN

    600, Congress Avenue
    14th Floor
    Austin, TX.
    78701
    USA
    +1 512 649 0340

    NEW YORK

    110 Wall St.,
    3rd Floor
    New York, NY.
    10005
    USA
    +1 212 432 5800

    CEO Latin America | ES

    • CONTACT
    • GENERAL ENQUIRIES
    • ADVERTISING
    • MEDIA KIT
    • DIRECTORY
    • TERMS AND CONDITIONS

    Editorials –
    george.hatfield@ceo-na.com
    Editor-in-Chief -
    paul.imison@ceo-na.com
    Advertising –
    media@ceo-na.com

    AUSTIN

    600, Congress Avenue
    14th Floor
    Austin, TX.
    78701
    USA
    +1 512 649 0340

    NEW YORK

    110 Wall St.,
    3rd Floor
    New York, NY.
    10005
    USA
    +1 212 432 5800

    CEO North America © 2022 - Sitemap

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • Business
      • Entrepreneur
      • Industry
      • Innovation
      • Management & Leadership
    • CEO Interviews
    • CEO Life
      • Art & Culture
      • Food
      • Health
      • Travel
      • Environment
    • Opinion
    • News
    • Multimedia

    © 2022 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password?

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In
    Are you sure want to unlock this post?
    Unlock left : 0
    Are you sure want to cancel subscription?